Is Curt Schilling bound for the Hall of Fame?

All of the hype surrounding the World Champion Boston Red Sox will come to a hilt tonight as the conquering hero makes his return from the Land of the Bloody Sock.

At approximately 7:07 p.m. with a game time temperature hovering just over a brisk 40 degrees, Curt Schilling and his mended ankle will amble up to the mound on Fenway Park. Schilling, as we all know by now, is the most hyped player on this Red Sox team. While Johnny Damon may be running around with a new wife and a book deal, it’s Schilling whose viewed as the man who brought the Red Sox the championship.

With all of the attention focused on Schilling’s heroics, it’s often hard to cut through the rhetoric. One article, written by The Chicago Tribune’s Phil Rogers, questioned Schilling’s motivation. Rogers doesn’t think Schilling can duplicate his successes from the past five seasons. “Success comes at a higher price as you get older,” Rogers wrote, “and the 38-year-old Schilling spent more than his share of the time mugging for the camera in the off-season. The bet here is the run of greatness he started in 2001 is due to take a downturn.”

On the other side of the coin are those members of Red Sox Nation who think Schilling is the best thing to happen to the Red Sox since the 1918 World Series. With all the hype surrounding Curt Schilling and his accomplishments over the last 12 months, his career perspective is often obscured. This is, after all, a pitcher who didn’t really break out until he turned 30 when he struck out 319 men. And while he’s won 20 games three times, those three times have all been since the turn of the millennium. Is Schilling, famous for his workhorse tendencies and off-the-charts pitching over the last four seasons, bound for enshrinement in Cooperstown?

Predicting a player’s Hall of Fame chances has, like most statistical evaluation in the rich field of baseball analysis, become something of a science. Bill James, one of the giants in the world of baseball statistics, has developed four different metrics for evaluating any player’s shot at the Hall of Fame.

First up is the black-ink test, the least scientific of the bunch. This is a test to see how often a player led the league in important statistics such as wins, ERA, strike outs, fewest walks, and so on. The gray-ink test looks to see how often a player finished in the top ten of the black-ink categories. Then, there is the Hall of Fame Career Standards Test and the Hall of Fame Monitor Test. Suffice it to say, both of these Jamesian creations require a lot of space to explain them. (If you’re interested in the statistics behind these methods, check out Baseball Reference’s detailed descriptions.)

As it stands right now, the Hall of Fame stats say that Curt Schilling is probably in Cooperstown but not definitely yet destined to be there. For the black in test, he scores a 40, where 40 is generally considered to be the bottom line of Hall of Fame measurements. On the gray ink test, he’s at 195, where 185 is the norm for the average Hall of Famer. Schilling, in other words, has been consistently in the top 10 of pitchers in his league. His Hall of Fame Standards test is at 42, where 50 is considered average, and his Hall of Fame Monitor test is at 151, where 100 denotes a likely Hall of Famer.

Outside of these metrics, what do Schilling’s career accomplishments tell us? In 17 years, Schilling has won just 184 games and only one Cy Young Award. While those wins rank him ninth among active players, numerous retired pitchers have won more than Schilling but aren’t in the Hall of Fame. These include Bert Blyleven and Jack Morris, two pitchers who probably should be enshrined in Cooperstown.

Currently, Schilling is sitting on 2745 career strike outs. That’s good for fourth among active players and 18th on the career list. Only Frank Tanana, Mickey Lolich, and Bert Blyleven (and his 3701 strike outs) are ahead of Schilling but no in the Hall. Considering that Schilling has at least two years left, he should finish his career with 3000 strike outs. Everyone who has reached that plateau except, inexplicably enough, Blyleven, has made it to the Hall. While the wins are lacking, that seems to be more due to factors outside of Schilling’s control. He’s often pitched well enough to win but has been victimized by bad offensive teams. As much as I would like to, it’s hard to argue with 3000 strike outs.

To seal the deal further, Schilling has turned in some amazing postseason performances, sutured ankle or otherwise. He has a career postseason record of 8-2 and two World Series rings. In 109.1 innings pitched, he’s given up just 79 hits and 22 walks while striking out 104, or just a shade under nine per nine innings. With an ERA of 2.06, he’s pitched four complete games and two shutouts. He won the World Series MVP in 2001 when he pitched Arizona to the championship.

In the end, this Yankee fan is forced to admit that, in spite of personal feelings about Curt Schilling and a few bouts with mediocrity every few years, Number 38 is headed for the Hall when he finally hangs up those blood-stained socks of his. What team his plaque will feature is an entirely different matter.

4 Responses to “Is Curt Schilling bound for the Hall of Fame?”


  1. 1 Ted Chan June 13, 2006 at 8:33 pm

    Are you the Ben Kabak that I know?

    In any case, as huge a Curt Schilling fan as I am, I think he’s out despite his pantheon quality post-season performance. The first half of his career just wasn’t good enough. Look at his comparables from Baseball Reference.

    Even Schilling himself said he was out when asked on WEEI 850 on Boston radio the other morning.

    Likely none of the pitchers he is comparable to, be it by age or cumulatively are in the Hall of Fame. I think he has a shot if and only if he has 3 more good seasons (this one included). He has already said he is going to walk away.

    Similar Pitchers View in Pop-up
    David Cone (914)
    Dazzy Vance (906) *
    Dwight Gooden (902)
    Kevin Brown (897)
    Jimmy Key (897)
    John Candelaria (893)
    Lon Warneke (890)
    Mike Cuellar (888)
    Mike Mussina (888)
    Bob Welch (880)
    Similar Pitchers through Age 38
    Kevin Brown (917)
    David Cone (914)
    Orel Hershiser (901)
    John Candelaria (890)
    Lew Burdette (884)
    Charley Root (880)
    John Smoltz (877)
    Dave Stieb (866)
    Tommy Bridges (865)
    Mike Cuellar (864)
    Most Similar by Age
    Ken Wright (981)
    Danny Frisella (984)
    Danny Darwin (973)
    Ken Forsch (984)
    Ron Robinson (972)
    Marty Pattin (972)
    Bill Hands (961)
    Scott Sanderson (958)
    Scott Sanderson (951)
    Scott Sanderson (952)
    Scott Sanderson (938)
    Bret Saberhagen (933)
    Bret Saberhagen (935)
    Kevin Brown (938)
    Kevin Brown (917)

  2. 2 Brian G. January 22, 2007 at 2:17 pm

    I think if Schilling has a quality year (20 wins would seal the deal, 15 would do) and the Sox make the playoffs, Schilling has a good shot at the Hall.

  3. 3 Denver1962 June 21, 2008 at 3:50 pm

    Hall of Fame, I am not sure what people are looking at. Half of his career he doesn’t even reach double digit wins, nor is he a work horse, few years with at least 200 innings pitched. if anybody should be int he HOF it should be Jack Morris.

  4. 4 Charle June 23, 2008 at 2:14 pm

    Denver1962…What are you talking about? Not a work horse? Among all other right-handers of Schillings era, he leads them all in complete games. All of them. Maddux, who is 25 behind him, is the closest. Know more facts before you make statements like that.


Comments are currently closed.



RSS River Ave. Blues

  • Sherman: Yanks considering six-man rotation for September, possibly 2015 August 23, 2014
    Via Joel Sherman: The Yankees are “strongly considering” using a six-man rotation in September and are at least “talking about” doing the same next year, pitching coach Larry Rothschild and Brian Cashman confirmed. “No doubt, you have to see how all the pieces fit, but I think it is something you have to take a […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New York Yanke […]
    Michael Axisa
  • Prado’s huge night leads Yankees to 4-3 walk-off win over ChiSox August 23, 2014
    Source: FanGraphs The start of Friday night’s series opener against the White Sox was not so good, but the ending was arguably the best of the season. Thanks to Martin Prado‘s big night, the Yankees walked off with a much-needed 4-3 win over Chicago’s south-siders. That’s two straight wins and four in the last six […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New York Ya […]
    Michael Axisa
  • Game 126: Almost August 22, 2014
    Three weeks ago, it looked like John Danks — tonight’s starter for the White Sox — would be wearing Yankees pinstripes in the near future. The team was connected to the left-hander in the days leading up the trade deadline but ultimately nothing came of it. That’s not the worst thing in the world, really. […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New York Yankees blo […]
    Michael Axisa
  • 8/22-8/24 Series Preview: Chicago White Sox August 22, 2014
    Your browser does not support iframes. One fourth place team leaves town, another comes in. Hopefully the Yankees do a better job of seizing the opportunity during this three-game weekend set against the White Sox than they did the Astros, eh? The Yankees and ChiSox split a four-game set on Chicago’s south side back in […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New Yo […]
    Michael Axisa
  • McCarthy open to re-signing with Yankees, calls NY a “great fit for me” August 22, 2014
    Via Dan Barbarisi: Following yesterday’s shutout win, Brandon McCarthy said he would be open to re-signing with the Yankees after the season. “Yeah. There wouldn’t be a question in my mind about that,” he said when asked about returning to New York. “I feel like it’s a great fit for me here. The guys here […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New York Yankees blo […]
    Michael Axisa
  • Reports: Red Sox to sign Rusney Castillo for six years, $72M August 22, 2014
    According to multiple reports, the Red Sox will sign Cuban free agent Rusney Castillo to a record six-year contract in the $72M range. The Yankees had Castillo in Tampa for a private workout and were said to have interest in him as a second baseman, but the other day we heard they “ended any pursuit” […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New York Yankees blogRepo […]
    Michael Axisa
  • Mailbag: A-Rod, Protected Pick, Pineda, Homers August 22, 2014
    I’ve got seven questions for you this week. If you want to send us anything, mailbag questions or comments or links or whatever, just use the Submit A Tip box in the sidebar at any time. Many asked: What about playing Alex Rodriguez at shortstop next season? We get asked this question a shocking number […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New York Yankees blogMa […]
    Michael Axisa
  • DotF: Judge’s hot hitting continues in Tampa’s win August 22, 2014
    Some notes, including a few roster moves courtesy of Nicholas Flammia, Nick Peruffo, and Donnie Collins. Baseball Prospectus posted a bunch of (free!) firsthand scouting reports of Yankees prospects today, including LHP Jacob Lindgren, C Gary Sanchez, OF Tyler Austin, and OF Mason Williams. Williams got absolutely crushed, which isn’t all that surprising, sa […]
    Michael Axisa
  • Thursday Night Open Thread August 21, 2014
    Your browser does not support iframes. Earlier today, MLB announced that Robinson Cano, Albert Pujols, Adam Jones, and Yasiel Puig will headline a group of players heading over to Japan to play a five-game All-Star series against the Japanese National Team in November. Ron Washington will manage. The rest of the roster will be unveiled […]Post from: River Av […]
    Michael Axisa
  • Yankees avoid sweep; McCarthy shuts out Astros 3-0 August 21, 2014
    I don’t think you could have asked for a better finish to the series considering how the first two games played out. Brandon McCarthy led the Yankees to a 3-0 shutout win over the Astros on Thursday afternoon in the fastest game in New Yankee Stadium history. This one took only two hours and seven […]Post from: River Ave. Blues A New York Yankees blogYankees […]
    Michael Axisa

Blog Stats

  • 60,384 hits

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: