Early All Star returns show questionable balloting

After a while, my mantra makes me sound like a broken record.

Fix the voting, I squawk, much like a parrot stuck on his favorite phrase or an old LP stuck in a scratched groove. Fix the voting.

When the American League All-Star Voting results were announced on Tuesday, I wasn’t too disappointed. The fans, at least, got most of it right, and the ones they got wrong were excusable. The lineup, had voting ended on May 31, would have looked like this:

C Jason Varitek
1B Tino Martinez
2B Brian Roberts
SS Miguel Tejada
3B Alex Rodriguez
OF Manny Ramirez
OF Vladimir Guerrero

OF Ichiro Suzuki
DH David Ortiz

The ones that do not deserve to be there, in my mind, were Tino Martinez and Manny Ramirez. Tino’s All Star balloting appearance was propelled by his homer streak and the adoration of the Yankee fans. His power is good this year. In fact, his ISO (Slugging – Batting Average) is nearly .300. But he is hitting just .245 with a .341 OBP, 12 home runs and 30 RBIs.

Instead of Tino, I submit for your consideration the current American League first baseman in fourth place: Mark Teixeira. Down in Texas, the Rangers’ first baseman is slugging his team into contention. He is hitting .295/.349/.539 with 13 home runs and 38 RBIs. Teixeira has also created 30 years compared to Tino’s 27.

Like Tino, Manny Ramirez was propelled to the top of the ballot box by devoted fans and easy name recognition. He is hitting just .257/.352/.492 with 11 home runs and 43 RBI. Considering that Manny usually tears up the league in April and May, I don’t think his subpar season merits All Star consideration.

Instead, let me present Manny’s teammate, Johnny Damon. Playing for a new contract, Damon is hitting .350/.401/.453. He has just one home run – a significant decrease over last year – but 26 RBIs from the leadoff spot. He has created 40 runs to Manny’s 36. At this point, Damon is more deserving of the All Star spot than Manny is.

Two “wrong” picks are not the end of the world. I thought maybe the fans could really pick out the most deserving players to play in the Mid-Summer Classic. (Hey, this time it counts, right?) But then the National League balloting results were announced, and half the lineup was out of place. I was distraught!

C Mike Piazza
1B Albert Pujols

2B Jeff Kent
SS Nomar Garciaparra
3B Scott Rolen
OF Carlos Beltran
OF Jim Edmonds
OF Ken Griffey, Jr.

As someone who wants to see the American League get home-field advantage in the World Series, I liked it. As a baseball fan, I hate it. Mike Piazza? The Mike Piazza of the .312 on-base percentage and .244 average? Ken Griffey, Jr and no sign of Bobby Abreu? Scott Rolen over Troy Glaus? (Even Chipper Jones managed more votes than Troy Glaus. Ken Griffey over Miguel Cabrera? Cabrera, the new kid in town, is a great player, and he’s fun to watch. But hey, you never know when Griffey’s hamstring might pop. And how about Jim Edmonds over someone more deserving such as Cliff Floyd?

Then, there is the upset of the voting. Albert Pujols is outpolling Derrek Lee by a two-to-one margin. Derrek Lee is currently the Triple Crown leader in the NL. He has led the charge as the Cubs have climbed to within 5.5 of the complacent Cards. While Pujols is off to his usually stellar start, what does a first baseman in Chicago have to do to get his just recognition?

Finally, we come at least to Nomar. I can’t wait to see Nomar hobble out to short during the All Star game. Is that part of his rehab plan? Did the voters forget that, before tearing his groin, Nomar had gotten a grand total of one extra base hit in his 51 at bats this year? Did they forget that he hasn’t played a game since April 20?

Just what is the All Star game about? I know I’ve said this before. If it’s about putting forward the league’s best players to win a game, it’s time to take voting out of the hands of the fan. If it’s about giving the audience what they want to see, then the game shouldn’t count, not when the truly deserving All Stars don’t get to start.

Fix the voting.

Advertisements

RSS River Ave. Blues

  • Game 43: A Big Test for Montgomery May 23, 2017
    Seven starts into his big league career, Jordan Montgomery has pitched like, well, most rookie pitches. Sometimes he looks great, sometimes he walks too many. That’s usually how it goes. Tonight will be a pretty big test for Montgomery even though the Royals are the worst offensive team in baseball. Kansas City will be the […] The post Game 43: A Big Test fo […]
    Mike Axisa
  • 2017 Draft: Adam Haseley May 23, 2017
    Adam Haseley | OF Background Haseley, 21, grew up outside Orlando, and went undrafted out of high school. After hitting only .275/.360/.407 during his freshman and sophomore seasons at Virginia, Haseley has broken out as a junior, and he currently owns a .400/.498/.688 batting line with 14 homers, ten steals, 40 walks, and only 19 […] The post 2017 Draft: Ad […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Aaron Hicks has been working out of first base, and hopefully the Yankees won’t need him there May 23, 2017
    All winter long, I and many others said there was no way the Yankees would get worse production from first base this year than what Mark Teixeira gave them last year. Teixeira hit .204/.292/.362 (76 wRC+) last season. And so far this season, Yankees first basemen are hitting .164/.276/.295 (59 wRC+), and that’s with Chris […] The post Aaron Hicks has been wo […]
    Mike Axisa
  • The Yankees have a bit of a strikeout problem right now May 23, 2017
    Last night, for only the eighth time in 19 games this month, the Yankees did not strike out 10+ times on offense. They struck out eight times, to be exact, and it helped that they faced Royals southpaw Jason Vargas, a finesse pitcher not known for missing bats. The Yankees have 18 double-digit strikeout games […] The post The Yankees have a bit of a strikeou […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Thoughts following Gleyber Torres’ promotion to Triple-A May 23, 2017
    Later tonight, top Yankees prospect Gleyber Torres is expected to play his first game with Triple-A Scranton. He was promoted from Double-A Trenton on Sunday. (The RailRiders were off yesterday.) I was planning to write something about the Torres promotion and what it all means, and it kinda morphed into a thoughts post, so here […] The post Thoughts followi […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Big flies and Big Mike lead Yankees to a 4-2 win over Royals May 23, 2017
    A two-game winning streak! It was a relatively stress-free win over the Royals on Monday. Good starting pitching, good hitting and good bullpen generally equal in a win and that’s pretty much what happened tonight. Big Mike! Tonight’s Michael Pineda was good, not perfect, but again, good. I’ll take a start like that any day. […] The post Big flies and Big Mi […]
    Sung-Min Kim
  • DotF: Austin continues rehab, Andujar has big game in AA win May 23, 2017
    Some notes to start the day: Double-A Trenton hitting coach Tom Slater broke down SS Gleyber Torres‘ swing frame-by-frame with Josh Norris, so make sure you check that out. Torres, as you know, was promoted to Triple-A Scranton yesterday. RHP Yefrey Ramirez was named the Double-A Eastern League Pitcher of the Week. He allowed three […] The post DotF: Austin […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Game 42: The Royals, Again May 22, 2017
    Once again, the Yankees are playing the Royals, this time in New York rather than Kansas City. The Yankees took two of three from the 2015 World Series champions at Kauffman Stadium last week. Since that series, both teams have lost two of three on the road. The Yankees did so in Tampa Bay, the […] The post Game 42: The Royals, Again appeared first on River […]
    Mike Axisa
  • 5/22 to 5/25 Series Preview: Kansas City Royals May 22, 2017
    This feels all too familiar, doesn’t it? The schedule-makers have a strange sense of humor. Nevertheless, the Yankees will spend the next seven games at home, hosting the teams with the worst and second-worst run differentials in the American League in back-to-back series. Playing twenty games in twenty days is never ideal, but playing subpar teams makes […] […]
    Domenic Lanza
  • The Masahiro Tanaka Problem May 22, 2017
    All things considered, it’s pretty incredible the Yankees are where they are even though Masahiro Tanaka has legitimately been one of the worst pitchers in baseball so far this season. Among the 94 pitchers with enough innings to qualify for the batting title, Tanaka ranks 91st in both ERA (6.56) and FIP (6.07). Yankees starters […] The post The Masahiro Tan […]
    Mike Axisa

Blog Stats

  • 62,411 hits

%d bloggers like this: