Rocky off-season leaves many wondering whither the Red Sox

The 2005 off-season started out with a bang for the Boston Red Sox. While the team made an early exit from the playoffs, their mid-November acquisition of Josh Beckett sent shockwaves throughout the AL East. However, a general manager conflict, an unhappy slugger, and a few lost free agents have many fans questioning the Sox’s ability to succeed in 2006.

At the end of November, it was hard to argue against the Red Sox chances. They had after all just landed Josh Beckett, a 25-year-old pitcher with a Yankee-killing reputation (albeit in just one game) and were sitting pretty among their American League East counterparts. But all was not well in Red Sox Nation.

Most notable for Boston during this winter of their discontent has been the GM soap opera. Theo Epstein, the darling of Boston, and Larry Lucchino, New England’s own Evil Emperor, suffered a meltdown in their relationship that led to Theo’s untimely departure from Boston and a scramble to find a replacement that would play itself out over the course of nearly a month.

The Red Sox headed into the Winter Meetings with a four-headed GM monster and made out well for themselves. They netted Josh Beckett, a league-average pitcher away from Pro Player Stadium, Guillermo Mota, and third baseman Mike Lowell in exchange for some highly touted prospects. They had seemingly found a starter who could take over for Curt Schilling as the ace of the team if the old Curt Schilling never returned, and they found a replacement for Bill Mueller, the incumbent third baseman who left the team through free agency. But the lustre of this deal would soon wear off.

While the Red Sox eventually named Jed Hoyer and Ben Cherington co-general managers, it was too late to repair the damage to the front office. The Boston media had already turned on Lucchino, one of the architects of the team’s recent success, and constant rumors of Epstein’s imminent return may have undermined Hoyer and Cherington’s attempts at establishing their own authority over the club. John Henry, the team’s owner, has addressed numerous rumors that he was reducing Lucchino’s power by denying them, and the players seem skeptical of the team’s administration right now.

On top of the GM soap opera came the news that Manny Ramirez, the soon-to-be 34-year-old slugger due $57 million over the next three years, wants out of Boston. For whatever reason, Manny is unhappy with his situation where he claims to have little privacy and is unhappy with management. So far, the team has not moved on the Manny situation. And who can blame them? It makes little sense for the team to trade a slugger with a career .314/.409/.599 line when they may have to pay his whole salary and wouldn’t be able to replace his bat in the lineup.

Meanwhile, the Sox sent away one of their disappointing players from 2005. After inking Edgar Renteria to a four-year, $40 million deal last winter, the team traded him to the Atlanta Braves for third base prospect Andy Marte. The Sox will also be paying some of Renteria’s salary. While the move was welcomed by both parties, it has opened a hole in the infield that has yet to be filled by a desirable candidate. While Mark Loretta and Tony Graffinino remain viable candidates to play second and short, it’s hard to say these two are the boppers the Sox may need.

With Manny’s unhappiness dangling over the team, the last few days have been disappointing if not disastrous for the team. First, the Red Sox lost their leadoff hitter and one of the chief Idiots Johnny Damon to what their fans call the New York Effin’ Yankees. While one of the chief Red Sox blogs (and one of the best baseball blogs around) has tried to convince themselves that Damon will not be missed, the truth is that the Red Sox are worse without Damon and at a disadvantage now that Damon is still playing within the division for their biggest rival. The Sox may yet find a replacement for Damon, but the defection hurts.

Then, over the last two days, the Red Sox lost out on two prizes: Troy Glaus and Kevin Millwood. The Texas Rangers signed Millwood to a five-year deal with an opt-out option for the fifth year. According to the Boston Herald, the Sox needed Millwood so that they could trade Bronson Arroyo or Matt Clement for a center fielder. Even Evan Brunell, Fire Brand founder and optimistic Red Sox fan, is finding this latest loss a little tough to swallow. While the impact of Millwood’s decision is mitigated by the Sox’s arm-rich farm system, the team does not want to ship off more young pitchers in order to win now. How this will sit with their judgmental fan base in 2006 is yet to be determined.

While Millwood opted for Texas, the Diamondbacks found a trading partner in the Toronto Blue Jays. Once again, the Sox lost out on a key potential cog to another division rival. While Glaus could have given the Sox the flexibility to trade Manny for another slugger or Andy Marte for a short stop such as Julio Lugo as had been rumored, the third baseman will instead head to a revamped Blue Jays team that hopes to give Boston and New York a run for their money next year.

As the Red Sox and their fans look forward to the end of 2005, questions are swirling around this team for 2006. Right now, the Red Sox are full of holes. They have a 32-year-old third baseman coming off a season that saw his OBP drop to .298. They have no center fielder, no leadoff man, and no short stop. Their starting first baseman has a total of 9 games of Major League experience at the position. They do not know whether Curt Schilling and Keith Foulke will resemble their 2005 performances or their 2004 performances, and Matt Clement forever remains an enigma as well. Meanwhile, no one knows whether Manny Ramirez or David Wells will still be on the team come April.

On top of all of this drama, the Sox have dealt with a few significant backlashes from the Johnny Damon deal as well. One was the news from Damon that he decided to jump to New York because of the shaky management picture, and he did not think that Manny would be in Boston next season. He wanted out. Now, it seems as though the Sox cannot land the free agents they want and cannot get the guys they need through trades. Just a few weeks ago, baseball writers thought the Yankees were the team suffering from a lack of free agent interest. It’s funny how the shoe is now on the other foot in this Boston-New York rivalry.

To fill in some of their missing pieces, the Red Sox may have to weigh the options of trading away some of the upper echelons of their farm system. They have quite a few almost-Major-League-ready players who are highly desirable bargaining chips. Other teams such as the Devil Rays, Mariners, and Indians have no real compelling reason to trade away Julio Lugo, Jeremy Reed, and Coco Crisp, respectively, for players of lesser value. But the Sox may not want to trade away future stars right now.

With a few months left before pitchers and catchers report for Spring Training, the Red Sox off-season is far from over. But the next few months will be key for the Sox hopes of capturing a fourth consecutive playoff berth in 2006.

Advertisements

10 Responses to “Rocky off-season leaves many wondering whither the Red Sox”


  1. 1 Wayne December 27, 2005 at 8:59 pm

    Sorry, Ben, but I don’t buy most of your arguments. I truly believe that the Sox did not want to resign Damon. Their paltry offers to him speak for themselves. In truth, as has been pointed out by Joe Sheehan (Prospectus), Rob Neyer (ESPN), and John Brattain (Hardball Times), Damon is an ordinary player when removed from Fenway Park. Let the Yankees pay him more than Miguel Tejada and Vlad Guerrero are making.

    Millwood is likely the 2006 winner of the Carl Pavano Award. He is an inconsistent pitcher who isn’t worth anything close to what he will be paid by the Texas Rangers. Glaus is a slow fragile, one dimensional player.

    The Sox are fine at the corners. Mike Lowell is a relatively young player coming off one bad year. Let’s see what he can do. Kevin Youkilis has earned a shot at a full time job. Let’s see what he can do.

    The Sox as of today have seven starters. Seven. Deal Wells. Deal Clement or Arroyo and you still have five. John Lester is very close. Abe Alvarez is a possible desperation option. With the bargaining chips the Sox have, I feel quite confident that they can close their holes at short and center between now and April.

    Remember, this team won 95 games last year, despite losing their closer and number one starter, both effectively for the season. Despite getting virtually no production from first or second base. Despite losing their right fielder for nearly half the season. The Sox led the league in runs scored last year with little or no production below the five slot. A front six of Youkilis, Loretta, Manny, Ortiz, Varitek and Nixon looks just fine to me.

  2. 2 NBarnes December 28, 2005 at 12:18 am

    What Wayne said. Panicing because the Yankees and the Blue Jays are throwing money at risky, mediocre, or both players is exactly how a team turns into the Mets. Glaus? Millwood? Injury risks waiting to happen. Damon is certain to decline over the next four years; his arm is already a wet noodle, and he won’t look so hot in LF.

  3. 3 Benjamin Kabak December 28, 2005 at 12:54 am

    NBarnes: I do agree that the Yankees are overpaying a bit for Johnny Damon and that the Blue Jays are hinges their hopes on a few unreliable pieces. However, the Sox were seriously engaged in negotiations for Millwood. The only reason they didn’t land him was because the Rangers gave him more years. It seems that the team is indeed trying to throw money at risky players, but these players aren’t biting.

    As for Wayne’s observation that the Sox led the league in runs scored last year, the 2006 iteration of the team won’t have Bill Mueller or Kevin Millar. They won’t have Johnny Damon or Edgar Renteria (a bust but he still contributed). They’ll have Varitek another year older and his second half was downright ugly. They have Loretta and Lowell filling in those holes. The lineup just doesn’t have the same pop anymore.

    But those are just my thoughts.

  4. 4 Wayne December 28, 2005 at 6:06 am

    Won’t have Kevin Millar? Praise the Lord. Ben, you’re right that Varitek will decline. However, Youkilis at 1b is a huge upgrade over Millar ’05. Loretta at 2b is a huge upgrade over 2/3Bellhorn-1/3TonyG. Trot missed 1/2 of last season, including time on the DL and time playing very beat up. At this point, we have seriously upgraded 3 spots in the lineup. I see little difference between Lowell and Mueller and they are hard to compare as one gives OBP, the other power. With Lowell’s Gold Glove, I’m happy with him.

    We have two holes to fill and plenty of chips to deal for them.

  5. 5 Tim December 28, 2005 at 9:27 am

    “the Sox were seriously engaged in negotiations for Millwood. The only reason they didn’t land him was because the Rangers gave him more years. It seems that the team is indeed trying to throw money at risky players, but these players aren’t biting.”

    What basis do you have for saying this? Do you have firsthand knowledge of the negotiations between Boston and Millwood/Boras? If the “only reason” the Sox didn’t land Millwood is because they were unwilling to go long on a guy who was arguably the third or fourth best pitcher in a bad 2005 FA lot, then I say good for them. There’s no reason the Sox FO should allow themselves to be bludgeoned into making a bad deal in a very, very weak free agent market just because the subset of fans who phone into WEEI is getting anxious.

  6. 6 Chip December 28, 2005 at 12:12 pm

    Also, I’m pretty sure the rumors about the sox offer to Millwood involve $30M-$35M, and that the Rangers heaped out $48M guaranteed, with incentives for a 5th year at an additional $60M. So, of course Millwood agreed to go somewhere where they were paying him twice as much. It had nothing to do with Boston not being an attractive place for free agents, it had to do the Rangers deciding that Millwood was worth significantly more to them than the Red Sox thought he was worth.

  7. 7 Andy December 28, 2005 at 3:25 pm

    How about offering Tampa Bay Lester for Baldelli; let them keep Galthraight (sp?)?

  8. 8 Wayne December 28, 2005 at 10:09 pm

    No, no, no, no no. Lester goes nowhere.

  9. 9 Benjamin Kabak December 29, 2005 at 2:35 am

    Tim: My sources for the statement I made on Millwood came from an article in Boston Globe this week. The article (found here) says that the Red Sox’s unwillingness to guarantee a fourth year or a no-trade clause coupled with the Rangers’ fourth year persuaded Millwood to take the deal with Texas.


  1. 1 Whither the Red Sox? at Three True Outcomes Trackback on December 27, 2005 at 2:25 pm
Comments are currently closed.



RSS River Ave. Blues

  • Offense wastes Tanaka’s gem, Yankees drop series opener 4-1 to Athletics May 27, 2017
    Source: FanGraphs I miss offense. I miss the days when the Yankees were putting up like seven runs a night and smacking dingers like Gary Sanchez circa August 2016. Those were the days. It was called April. The bats were mostly silent Friday night in the series opener against the Athletics. The final score was […] The post Offense wastes Tanaka’s gem, Yankee […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Game 45: Will the Real Tanaka Please Stand Up? May 26, 2017
    Masahiro Tanaka has been one of the worst starting pitchers in Major League Baseball this year. That isn’t hyperbole, either – Mike went into great detail about his struggles earlier this week. And he seems to be getting worse, with a 10.50 ERA/9.36 FIP since he shut out the Red Sox on April 27. Tanaka […] The post Game 45: Will the Real Tanaka Please Stand […]
    Domenic Lanza
  • 2017 Draft: Jake Burger May 26, 2017
    Jake Burger | 3B Background The 21-year-old Burger is a St. Louis kid who went undrafted out of high school, but has since developed into one of the top power hitters in the country at Missouri State. He is currently hitting .346/.459/.693 with 20 home runs and more walks (38) than strikeouts (30) in 52 […] The post 2017 Draft: Jake Burger appeared first on […]
    Mike Axisa
  • 5/26 to 5/28 Series Preview: Oakland Athletics May 26, 2017
    Mother nature gave the Yankees a much-needed respite yesterday, splitting their twenty games in twenty days down the middle. Their series against the A’s now represents the first game in a ten-in-ten stretch, which is far less daunting. The Last Time They Met The Yankees visited Oakland for a four-game series this time last year […] The post 5/26 to 5/28 Ser […]
    Domenic Lanza
  • Yankeemetrics: Pitching, Power and Wins (May 22-24) May 26, 2017
    Bronx Bombers Born Again The Yankees returned to the Bronx on Monday and kicked off their seven-game homestand with a sweet comeback win over the Royals, 4-2. Michael Pineda continued to shed the enigma label that had defined his time in pinstripes leading up to this season with his eighth straight start of at least […] The post Yankeemetrics: Pitching, Powe […]
    Katie Sharp
  • Mailbag: Wade, Hand, Berrios, Greinke, Tanaka, Robertson May 26, 2017
    There are 13 questions and eleven answers in this week’s mailbag. Remember to use the RABmailbag (at) gmail (dot) com email address to send us any questions. We get a lot of them each week, so don’t take it personally if yours doesn’t get picked. Keep trying. Many asked: Talk to me about Tyler Wade. […] The post Mailbag: Wade, Hand, Berrios, Greinke, Tanaka, […]
    Mike Axisa
  • DotF: Mateo has huge day in Tampa’s doubleheader sweep May 26, 2017
    RHP Brady Lail has rejoined Triple-A Scranton, reports Matt Kardos. The RailRiders have been short a starting pitcher since RHP Bryan Mitchell was called back up a few days ago. Lail solves that problem. RHP Colten Brewer was sent to Double-A Trenton to clear a roster spot for Lail. Triple-A Scranton was rained out. No […] The post DotF: Mateo has huge day i […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Thursday Night Open Thread May 25, 2017
    The Yankees were rained out today, but not even rain can stop HOPE Week. Today the Yankees held an event at Yankee Stadium to benefit A Moment of Magic, an organization dedicated to helping sick children by “restoring the magic of believing at a time when a child needs to ‘just be a kid’ and […] The post Thursday Night Open Thread appeared first on River Ave […]
    Mike Axisa
  • 2017 Draft: Bubba Thompson May 25, 2017
    Bubba Thompson | OF Background Thompson, 18, attends McGill-Toolen Catholic High School in Mobile, Alabama, where he plays both baseball and football. He’s a good quarterback recruit who received Division I scholarship offers for both sports, though he committed to attend Alabama, where he’ll play baseball only. Odds are it won’t matter. Thompson is expected […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Finding a second gear after a sizzling first act May 25, 2017
    There are always certain phases of the major league season. The highs and lows, the streaks and skids, fluctuating from month to month and week to week. Unlike last season, the Yankees began 2017 on fire. The start seemed reminiscent of 2010, when the team got off to a roaring start coming off a championship. […] The post Finding a second gear after a sizzli […]
    Steven Tydings

Blog Stats

  • 62,416 hits

%d bloggers like this: