Beat writer’s vitriol against Belle misdirected

The post-Hall of Fame voting backlash grew in leaps and bounds on Monday as Chicago Tribune writer Teddy Greenstein issued a nasty attack against the former left fielder.

David Pinto’s Baseball Musings site directed me to this story today. In it, Greenstein rails against Belle’s behavior:

He got only 40 votes, or one for every 10 that Bruce Sutter received.

So why do I still believe that Albert Belle got way more Hall of Fame support than he deserved?

Oh, yeah. Because I covered him in 1998 when he played for the White Sox.

I saw him curse at reporters. Saw him react callously after accidentally flinging a bat into the stands that bloodied the face of a 10-year-old girl. Saw him pile up meaningless stats before sparse crowds. Saw his teammates and coaches revile him.

Greenstein, with his first-hand knowledge of Belle, has a very selective memory. We’ll get to that in a second. First, another excerpt:

But now there’s a segment that says Belle’s sins shouldn’t matter, that his numbers should merit an acceptance speech.

The Hall of Fame voting process has become politicized, they say. If you’re a baseball writer who takes into account a player’s off-the-field behavior, you’re superficial and petty for holding a grudge.

What a crock that is. Character counts. If it didn’t, Pete Rose would be adding “HOF” to all those autographs he hawks.

In my opinion, Greenstein’s justifications for denying Albert Belle the vote fall flat on this front. How many people enshrined in the Hall of Fame are of poor character either on the field or off?

Let’s look at Ty Cobb, one of the game’s greatest hitters and biggest bigots to every step foot on the field of play. There’s no need to rehash every crime Cobb committed, but it’s safe to say that he hated non-white people.

On the field, did Cobb have any more integrity than Belle? He sat out the last day of the 1910 season so that he could win a car by capturing the batting title. You can’t find a more meaningless statistic. He played mean baseball, sliding in to second spikes up taking out more than a few second baseman in his days. Finally, he was so popular among his teammates that his funeral drew a grand total of three other baseball players. Cobb, one of the game’s greatest, was hardly a nice guy. He gets a free pass.

Then there is the more recent example of Kirby Puckett. Like Belle, Puckett saw his career cut short by a devastating injury. For 12 years, he was one of the game’s greatest hitters just like Belle was one of the game’s greatest sluggers for the same period of time. Ten consecutive All Star appearances, a few Gold Gloves and batting titles as well as some World Series heroics earned Puckett a trip to Cooperstown. Furthermore, he had the reputation of being a nice guy. But was he?

Hardly. Since retirement, more has come out about Puckett’s personality than many of his biggest fans wish to admit. In 2002, Puckett was charged with groping a woman in Minnesota. Then, he and his wife went through a bitter divorce period. In March of 2003, Puckett’s story was plastered on the front of Sports Illustrated. According to the SI article:

Laura Nygren, whom SI describes as Puckett’s “mistress of many years,” told the magazine that Puckett resumed an affair with her just seven weeks after he was married in 1986 — then cheated on Nygren with numerous other women.

After the onset of glaucoma in his right eye forced him to retire in 1996, Puckett began committing lewd acts in public, such as urinating in mall parking lots, Nygren told SI. Her relationship with the ex-ballplayer ended last March after he allegedly threatened her and she obtained a temporary order of protection.

Where’s the outrage from Greenstein over Puckett? Now, Puckett and Cobb are just two of many players in the Hall who didn’t make it on their personalities. Mickey Mantle was a big drunk. Joe DiMaggio and Ted Williams had their own issues. The list just goes on and on.

When I filled out a mock ballot for the Hall, I voted for Albert Belle. It was a tough decision because the Hall rules explicitly mandate that voters weigh character as well as baseball prowess. Maybe Belle deserves to be in the Hall; maybe he doesn’t. But it is not reasonable for a beat writer with a Hall vote to hang Belle out to dry without giving other stars already enshrined in Cooperstown the same treatment.

Advertisements

3 Responses to “Beat writer’s vitriol against Belle misdirected”


  1. 1 Lance Richardson January 18, 2006 at 12:12 am

    Belle is, purely based on his numbers, a borderline candidate. His character should, and will, keep him out.
    Cobb was an asshole, but his on-field qualifications are overwhelming. Only a complete dolt would compare Belle’s case to that of Cobb. Ditto Williams, Dimaggio, and Mantle.
    Puckett would likely not have been elected had his less-than-desirable personal traits been known at the time he became eligible. He should not have been elected, regardless.
    If Belle belongs, then Al Rosen, Ted Kluszewski , Norm Cash, Eric Davis, and every other guy who was brilliant for half a decade (without being a son-of-a-bitch) belongs.
    But none of them are HOF material. And neither is Joey Belle.
    DUH…

  2. 2 Benjamin Kabak January 18, 2006 at 12:26 am

    Lance: I just wanted to make one thing clear: At this point, I think I agree with you. While I put Belle on my ballot, looking at his numbers and his comparables to other HOF candidates has convinced me that he probably doesn’t belong. However, I am just not comfortable with voters taking such a harsh line against him without considering (a) who else is in the Hall and (b) his on-field contributions. Why pick on Belle just because a few writers same him “up close” for a while during his career? These same writers extol the virtues of players they never got to know and probably wouldn’t have liked had they gotten to know them.

  3. 3 susan mullen January 21, 2006 at 9:06 pm

    I appreciate all your work & attention to detail. But, the HOF has rules. They
    do not say you should consider whomever else might be in the HOF.


Comments are currently closed.



RSS River Ave. Blues

  • Tuesday Night Open Thread January 24, 2018
    ?Want to work for the Yankees? They’re looking for a Player Development Quantitative Analyst. You have to be extremely qualified and willing to both travel a lot and not make much money. That’s usually how these baseball jobs go. Front office staffer is not the most financially rewarding position. But, it is a job in […] The post Tuesday Night Open Thread ap […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Masahiro Tanaka won the slow 2017-18 offseason by avoiding it entirely January 23, 2018
    Defining the winners of the 2017-18 MLB offseason is a difficult task. Free agent signings have been sparse and few blockbuster trades have reshaped the competitive landscape. There hasn’t been one team, perhaps outside the Angels, that has clearly gone from pretender to contender in the past few months. Surely, Giancarlo Stanton and Marcell Ozuna […] The po […]
    Steven Tydings
  • Prospect Profile: Thairo Estrada January 23, 2018
    Thairo Estrada | IF Background Thairo Estrada signed out of Bejuma, Venezuela for the bargain price of $49,000 way back in November of 2012. He was relatively unheralded, as evidenced by both the price tag and how late he signed, and was something of an afterthought in a class in which the Yankees jumped all […] The post Prospect Profile: Thairo Estrada appe […]
    Domenic Lanza
  • Thoughts three weeks before pitchers and catchers report to Spring Training January 23, 2018
    We are exactly three weeks away from the biggest non-news day of the year. Pitchers and catchers reporting marks the beginning of Spring Training and the beginning of the long marathon that is the new baseball season, but nothing really happens that day. Still exciting though. Anyway, I have some thoughts, so let’s get to […] The post Thoughts three weeks be […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Monday Night Open Thread January 23, 2018
    ?Four years ago today, the Yankees got their man and signed Masahiro Tanaka to a seven-year contract. For a while that offseason it appeared he wouldn’t be posted, but MLB and NPB worked things out, and Tanaka has been a Yankee ever since. Even after the elbow injury and his rough 2017 regular season, Tanaka […] The post Monday Night Open Thread appeared fir […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Yankees land six on Baseball America’s top 100 prospects list January 22, 2018
    Spring Training is three weeks away and that means it is top 100 prospect season. All the usual publications will be updating their lists in the coming days and weeks. Earlier today the gang at Baseball America released their 2018 top 100 prospects list, which is topped by Braves OF Ronald Acuna. Angels RHP/DH Shohei […] The post Yankees land six on Baseball […]
    Mike Axisa
  • The case for trading Brett Gardner to make room for Darvish January 22, 2018
    The other day, Steven wrote about the rationale of trading David Robertson to clear some salary room to fit Yu Darvish’s hypothetical contract under the $197 million luxury tax threshold. Today, I’m here to make a case for trading away another established veteran player with a +$10M salary: Brett Gardner. We’ve talked about the Yankees’ […] The post The case […]
    Sung-Min Kim
  • Sorting out the Yankees’ potential non-roster Spring Training invitees for 2018 January 22, 2018
    Pitchers and catchers report to Tampa three weeks from tomorrow, and at some point soon, likely within the next two weeks, the Yankees will announce their 2018 Spring Training invitees. These are non-40-man roster players who get a chance to come to big league camp to strut their stuff. Some non-roster invitees are top prospects, […] The post Sorting out the […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Fan Confidence Poll: January 22nd, 2018 January 22, 2018
    2017 Regular Season Record: 91-71 (858 RS, 660 RA, 100-62 pythag. record), second in ALE 2017 Postseason Record: 7-6 (51 RS, 42 RA), won AL WC Game, won ALDS, lost ALCS Top stories from last week: There continue to be rumors connecting the Yankees to Yu Darvish. Unless he signs dirt cheap, there’s no way […] The post Fan Confidence Poll: January 22nd, 2018 a […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Weekend Open Thread January 21, 2018
    ?I finally had a chance to read Kiley McDaniel’s piece on the stats vs. scouts debate, which really isn’t a debate anymore. Every team uses both. There are a few clubs that lean analytical — from what I understand, the Rays use algorithms for basically everything, including the draft — but the very best organizations […] The post Weekend Open Thread appeared […]
    Mike Axisa

Blog Stats

  • 62,643 hits

%d bloggers like this: