Teixeira, Giles deals don’t match up

Let’s look at two players who avoided arbitration today: Rangers’ first baseman Mark Teixeira and Braves’ second baseman Marcus Giles.

These two days were announced within hours of each other. Giles signed a one-year $3.85 million deal with the Braves while MVP candidate Teixeira got a two-year $15.4 million deal from Texas. Over at Baseball Musings, David Pinto opined that Teixeira’s signing suggested that Marcus Giles is underpaid.

While he may not have matched Teixeira’s .301/.379/.575 43-homer season, Giles’ .291/.365/.461 line from the second base position is worth more than half of one year of Teixeira’s deal. Or at least that’s how the argument goes. Let’s look at some other numbers.

For this chart, I’m going to compare Teixeira and Giles across three sabermetric measurements. The first is Win Shares, a Jamesian stat that relates a player’s individual stats to the number of wins he contributed to the team. Three win shares is equal to one win.

The second is VORP or Value Over Replacement Player. VORP is defined thusly: “The number of runs contributed beyond what a replacement-level player at the same position would contribute if given the same percentage of team plate appearances.” A replacement player is the next available option; that means, either the first guy called up to the Majors from AAA or the option the waiver wire.

The third is WARP-3, a Baseball Prospectus stat, that looks at Wins Above Replacement Level. The rational is similar to that of VORP.

Win Shares VORP WARP-3
Marcus Giles 23 48.8 8.1
Mark Teixeira 33 73.1 10.5

What we see first is very little variation across the three statistics. Based on Win Shares, Giles contributed 7.6 wins while Teixeira contributed 11. Based on VORP, Teixeira’s value was approximately 1.5 times that of Giles’. Based on WARP-3, Giles was 8.1 wins better than replacement while Teixeira was just 2.4 wins better than Giles.

So what these numbers show is that David Pinto’s original feeling was correct. These salaries do not match up with the production offered by these two players. Either Teixeira is being overpaid or Giles is being underpaid.

It’s hard to say that Teixeira is underpaid simply because he will be 26 in April and has gotten steadily better each year. He ought to be a perennial contender for the MVP award and has a Gold Glove, for what that’s worth, as well. The Rangers’ doling out $7.7 million a year for his services seems more than reasonable.

Giles on the other hand is certainly underpaid. He’s one of the game’s top second baseman and, at 27, is entering his peak player years. He doesn’t enjoy the same home park benefits that Teixeira enjoys in Texas. Even so, his production is clearly not that inferior to Teixeira’s.

With two players near the top of their respective positions locked up to contracts on the same day, it’s interesting to compare them and wonder what happened. Here’s one solution: Maybe Scott Boras, Teixeira’s agent, is really that much better of an agent that Joe Bick, the man representing Giles. For all the hype and negative publicity surrounding Boras, he really just might be that much better at getting his clients the deals they deserve (and sometimes even the deals they don’t deserve).

Advertisements

5 Responses to “Teixeira, Giles deals don’t match up”


  1. 1 Dave January 18, 2006 at 12:46 pm

    An important thing to remember here is that lineup spots are scarce, so the more you can cram into one, the better off you are. Because of the scarcity, the incremental change in going from a 20 VORP to a 40 VORP player is a lot different than going from a 40 VORP player to a 60 VORP player. This also has to do with the relative scarcities of 60 VORP, 40 VORP, and 20 VORP players. So, yes, Teixeira is getting paid more, but he’s one of very few people in the upper echeleon. That counts for something.

  2. 2 eric January 18, 2006 at 12:52 pm

    Players deserve whatever contracts they get. Scott Boras doesn’t have magic pixy dust that forces Tom Hicks to sign ridiculous contracts.

  3. 3 jer January 18, 2006 at 1:45 pm

    As well, some players just don’t mind taking a bit less than market to stay where they are happy. I think Atlanta is one of those classy organizations that a player would probably like to stay in, as long as they are in the ballpark (hah!) of their percieved value. Unless, of course, you are Rafael Furcal and are looking for the team who throws down the biggest pile of cash on your desk. If you were a player and money didn’t matter, who would you play for: The Dodgers (a mess!), or Atlanta (14 consecutive trips to post-season).

  4. 4 Benjamin Kabak January 18, 2006 at 1:58 pm

    Eric: Scott Boras may, however, have better negotiating skills than Bick. It’s just an idea I’ve tossed out. I’m certainly not married to it.

  5. 5 Freddy Toliver January 18, 2006 at 2:07 pm

    I think there are a few aspects to each player, contract, and team that you haven’t mentioned that might explain the difference in contracts.

    1) Teixiera is more important to his team as a superstar and keystone player than is Giles. Teixiera is the face of the Rangers, while Giles is, to most fans at least, not close to being the best player on his team or the most marketable commodity.

    2) Teixiera is a power hitter while Giles is an all-around type hitter. Players like Giles always get lesser contracts compared to players that do one thing really really well, whether it is power or speed. As an example, look at Soriano’s numbers – He’s similar to Giles and I bet his WS, VORP, & WARP3 are somewhere between Giles & Teixiera. He was paid almost as much in 2005 as Teixiera will get in 2006. It’s not right, but it is real.

    3) Giles has a very bad injury history. He missed 3 months in his 2nd season, then two more months in his 4th season. I think this might contribute to getting a lesser contract.

    4) Maybe the teams are revealing something about their plans with Teixiera and Giles with these contracts. Teixiera is obviously the key player on the Rangers and they want to continue that. Giles might be viewed now as a one-year player and the Braves will take their chances with his free agency or even plan to let him leave via FA if prospects like Betemit or Hernandez can replace him.


Comments are currently closed.



RSS River Ave. Blues

  • Open Thread: March 23rd Camp Notes March 23, 2017
    Your browser does not support iframes.The Yankees neither won nor lost today. They tied. First of the spring. The Yankees were down 5-0, then they chipped away and tied the game in the top of the ninth. There’s the ol’ Fighting Spirit. Aaron Hicks had a double and a walk while Aaron Judge had a […] The post Open Thread: March 23rd Camp Notes appeared first o […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Could Didi Gregorius’ injury be Rob Refsnyder’s opportunity? March 23, 2017
    Didi Gregorius‘ injury is unfortunate in every way, even if he may only miss a month of the season. The Yankees don’t have a ready-made replacement and, much more importantly, a key cog of their future has to deal with an injury that can set him back after he made strides last season and hoped […] The post Could Didi Gregorius’ injury be Rob Refsnyder’s oppo […]
    Steven Tydings
  • The Middle Relief Duo [2017 Season Preview] March 23, 2017
    The Yankees have had an elite bullpen most every year for what feels like an eternity at this point, owing largely to the incomparable Mariano Rivera, and the ability to churn out high-end relievers that would close for most teams (particularly David Robertson and Dellin Betances, who spent most of their time with the team pitching […] The post The Middle Re […]
    Domenic Lanza
  • Spring Training Game Thread: Montgomery’s Big Chance March 23, 2017
    This afternoon left-hander Jordan Montgomery will make his first and possibly only Grapefruit League start. The Yankees have two open rotation spots and two open bullpen spots, and Montgomery has opened enough eyes this spring that he’s now being considered for the Opening Day roster. Today will be his best chance to show what he’s […] The post Spring Traini […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Jordan Montgomery and the prospect of an Opening Day roster spot March 23, 2017
    Later today left-hander Jordan Montgomery will make his first Grapefruit League start as the Yankees begin to bear down and really evaluate  their Opening Day roster candidates. They have two open rotation spots and two open bullpen spots, and lots of guys competing for them. Montgomery has pitched his way into Opening Day roster consideration […] The post J […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Open Thread: March 22nd Camp Notes March 22, 2017
    Your browser does not support iframes.The Spring Training of our dreams continued with another win this afternoon. Greg Bird crushed two no-doubt home runs, and I’m pretty sure the first one sailed out of the stadium. It looks like it cleared the chain link fence in center field in the first clip above, no? Chase […] The post Open Thread: March 22nd Camp Not […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Piecoro: Yanks believed to have some interest in Nick Ahmed March 22, 2017
    According to Nick Piecoro, the Yankees are believed to have some level of interest in Diamondbacks shortstop Nick Ahmed. Arizona has plenty of middle infielders (Ketel Marte, Chris Owings, Brandon Drury, Daniel Descalso) and they reportedly started gauging interest in Ahmed a few days ago. The Yankees will be without Didi Gregorius for a few […] The post Pie […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Same All-Star reliever but with minor concerns [2017 Season Preview] March 22, 2017
    For the last three years, I have essentially marked games as wins in my mind whenever Dellin Betances comes in. Sure, there have been a few blown saves here and there, but for the most part, the Yankees win when Dellin comes into the game whether they lead or are tied. And it isn’t just […] The post Same All-Star reliever but with minor concerns [2017 Season […]
    Steven Tydings
  • Spring Training Game Thread: In Search of a Shortstop March 22, 2017
    Thanks to Didi Gregorius‘ shoulder injury, the Yankees suddenly have an opening at shortstop that will last for at least the first few weeks of the regular season. They have a small army of okay-ish fill-in shortstops, and now they have to sort through them and figure out who can best handle the job. Opening […] The post Spring Training Game Thread: In Searc […]
    Mike Axisa
  • It’s official: Yankees name Greg Bird starting first baseman March 22, 2017
    As expected, Greg Bird has officially been named the starting first baseman. Joe Girardi made the announcement this morning, according to Andrew Marchand. Bird is hitting .421/.500/.947 with four home runs and eleven extra-base hits this spring, the most in baseball. He’s been the team’s best hitter all Spring Training. Bird, 24, missed all of […] The post I […]
    Mike Axisa

Blog Stats

  • 62,319 hits

%d bloggers like this: