Lusting for Clemens, Pettitte brings back old Yankee memories

Dreams of 2000 are dancing in the heads of Yankee fans.

Jon Heyman, sports columnist for Newsday, is the one to blame for these pipe dreams. In Monday’s column, Heyman wrote that the Yankees are trying to convince Roger Clemens to join them for the 2006 campaign.

If Clemens opts for retirement or another season in Astros, the Yankees are lusting after Andy Pettitte, a pitcher they never should have lost in the first place. According to Heyman, the Yankees recognize that Pettitte’s contract, like nearly every Astros contract these days, is heavily backloaded. The Astros owe Pettitte $10.5 million in 2006 and $17.5 million in 2006. If Houston falls out of contention, the Yankees would be more than willing to assume the financial risk to get Pettitte back in pinstripes.

At least, those are the plans, according to Heyman. But why not both of them? Hey, these are the Yankees we’re talkin’ about. They’re rolling in dough. They had Clemens and Pettitte a few years ago. Why can’t they have Pettitte, Clemens, Randy Johnson, and Mike Mussina all pitching together? It would be the geriatric pitching convention. But age aside, how would the Yankees’ finances hold up with Clemens or Pettitte or both on board?

Currently, according to the excellent Hardball Dollars site, the Yankees owe players a guaranteed $183.77 million in 2006. That does not include the approximately $3 million Shawn Chacon will make or the league minimum doled out to Robinson Cano and Andy Phillips for their services this year. With those three included, the Yanks’ payroll will probably hit $187.5 million on Opening Day. Considering that the 2005 payroll was over $210 million, this is clearly a step in the right direction for the Bombers.

That is, unless they sign Clemens. Last year, Roger Clemens made $18 million, the most ever for a pitcher. And he earned every penny of it. He pitched to a 1.87 ERA and brought the Astros to their first World Series appearance. Despite his age, there’s little reason to believe that Clemens would regress too much. Were he to sign with the Yankees he would be pitching in the offensive-rich AL East instead of the fairly weak NL Central. He would have to face the Red Sox, Blue Jays, and Devil Rays. And he would probably cost the Yankees upwards of $15-18 million, bringing payroll closer to 2005’s astronomical figure.

With Clemens, the Yankees would become even more favored to win the AL title. But they would be spending more money than they wish. General Manager Brian Cashman has expressed a desire to build a leaner Yankee team, but the Bombers are clearly willing to make an exception if it means landing Roger Clemens for one last tour of duty. And, heck, the Yankees already are paying Clemens nearly $1 million in deferred salary in 2006. What’s a few more million?

Now, what if Clemens decides to retire? What if he signs with Houston but falls apart midway through the season? The Yankee fans, according to Heyman, will be rooting for the Astros to struggle because Andy Pettitte awaits on the horizon.

But Pettitte doesn’t really fit into Brian Cashman’s masterplan either. For 2006, the Yankees could easily take on Pettitte’s $10 million. In fact, I still can’t get over the fact that they let him go in the first place following the 2003 season. So if they got him back this year, it wouldn’t break the bank. The Yankees routinely pick up bulky contracts at the trade deadline. Sometimes it pays off (David Justice); sometimes it does not.

The problem is for 2007. The Yankees would owe Pettitte $17.5 million ($10 million in salary and $7.5 million in deferred payments). This would mean that the Yanks would owe ten players $123 million. They would be 15 players short of a full roster and already just a few million behind the next highest salary. It would hardly be financially prudent for the Yanks to paying so many players in their mid- to late-30s a lot of money.

Additionally, the Yankees would have to ship away a highly regarded prospect to land Pettitte. Even if the Yankees were willing to assume the salary, Pettitte wouldn’t come cheap, and the Astros know that. As the Yankees are interested in rebuilding a depleted farm system, the acquisition of Pettitte could throw a wrench into those plans.

So as Spring Training approaches and reporters look for stories, I can believe that the Yankees are interested in acquiring Roger Clemens, Andy Pettitte, or both. But when October rolls around, I certainly won’t be surprised if neither of them are pitching in the Bronx. These are just dreams from a long-gone dynasty.


9 Responses to “Lusting for Clemens, Pettitte brings back old Yankee memories”

  1. 1 Marsha February 7, 2006 at 10:33 am

    NO, NO, NO. The Yanks do not need Clemens. Now Andy Pettitte is another story but his pricetag sure is high. Biggest mistake was letting him get away in the first place.

  2. 2 Wayne's world February 7, 2006 at 10:57 am

    Marsha has certainly proven that she knows how to spell “no.” Anyway, I think if the Astros dealt Pettitte, they could kiss goodbye to Clemens. I also don’t think that Cashman could be lured into doing something stupid like giving up a great pitching prospect for Pettitte even if they have one. And George never loved him anyway. The problem with Pettitte is that he could have another great season; but in any given start, he could also blow out his elbow and end his season. Too risky at this stage of his career.

  3. 3 Steve February 7, 2006 at 11:43 am

    Here’s the big problem. If the Yankees want to trade for a big name player, Cano or Wang seemingly would have to be involved. Cashman’s made it pretty clear this offseason that he’s not willing to part with Cano, and probably Wang, for that matter.

    The only way I see either of those two players being moved is if the Yankees are really struggling by the trading deadline.

  4. 4 J February 7, 2006 at 1:17 pm

    Clemens was extremely impressive this past season, but as Ben said it was in the NL Central… not the AL-East… Can he really last much longer at his age and the amount of money necessary to bring him over would be crazy…

    He should give it one more go around with the Astro’s and then hang it up…

  5. 5 Lee "Baby" Sims February 7, 2006 at 11:45 pm

    They Yanks did not let Pettitte go. He signed for less money than the Yanks offered to be closer to home. Pettitte later recanted his statements about the Yanks not wanting him or fielding a competitive offer. It was Andy’s choice to leave.

  6. 6 Benjamin Kabak February 7, 2006 at 11:48 pm

    I don’t recall Pettitte recanting those statements. Do you remember, Lee, where you saw that? The latest I remember on that front was that Pettitte left because he wasn’t impressed with the Yankee effots to re-sign him and he was willing to field the Astros’ offer because it was closer to home.

  7. 7 Lee "Baby" Sims February 8, 2006 at 1:45 pm

    It was during this season, if I remember correctly. I will try to dig up some proof.

  8. 8 Lee "Baby" Sims February 8, 2006 at 2:06 pm

    Here’s an aside from Steve Goldman on the Yanks having offered more money, 2nd pp:

    That’s all I have for now.

  9. 9 Lee "Baby" Sims February 9, 2006 at 2:27 am

    Sorry about the length of the piece but here goes from Buster Olney in 2003:

    The Yankees did try to work out a deal with him over
    the last six weeks, but now Pettitte is gone, having
    agreed to a three-year deal with the Houston Astros.
    According to a baseball source, the Yankees offered
    Pettitte a three-year, $30 million deal shortly after
    the World Series, telling Pettitte this was just an
    opener, and that the team was ready to offer more.
    Pettitte’s agents countered with a three-year concept:
    $51 million, with enough deferred money to take down
    the real average annual value to $15 million. The
    agents then informed the Yankees that Pettitte wanted
    to try free agency, and with that, Yankees’ executives
    decided to back off in good faith to honor Pettitte’s
    A Yankees’ official says the team did check in
    repeatedly with Pettitte’s representatives, nudging
    them to move things along — and when they did not get
    a response, they made the trade for Javier Vazquez,
    out of a growing concern that Pettitte ultimately
    would sign with Houston, to be closer to home.
    Finally, as Pettitte neared a deal with the Astros on
    Wednesday, the Yankees offered a three-year, $39
    million contract, about $7.5 million more than the
    Houston deal. The agents countered with a four-year,
    $52 million request, and told the Yankees that even if
    they agreed to those terms, Pettitte might still sign
    with the Astros; Pettitte was getting pressure from
    within his family to stay at home.

Comments are currently closed.

RSS River Ave. Blues

  • Mailbag: Bumgarner, Stanton, Wade, Wheeler Walker, Soroka April 20, 2018
    Got a dozen questions in this week’s mailbag. It’s nice to have actual baseball to mailbag about again rather than offseason hypotheticals. Anyway, RABmailbag (at) gmail (dot) com is where you can send your questions each week. I’ll get to as many as I can. Brian asks: Assuming the Giants continue to struggle, I would […] The post Mailbag: Bumgarner, Stanton […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Yanks 4, Blue Jays 3: Bullpen picks up the slack in Sabathia’s return from the disabled list April 20, 2018
    Wouldn’t you know it, the Yankees have now won three of their last four games. Four of their last six too. What’s everyone so mad about? The Yankees opened this 18 games in 18 days stretch with a 4-3 win over the Blue Jays on Thursday night. Sabotaged by the Defense Every game, without fail, […] The post Yanks 4, Blue Jays 3: Bullpen picks up the slack in Sa […]
    Mike Axisa
  • DotF: Sheffield and Nelson have strong starts April 20, 2018
    The Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders had a scheduled off-day. Double-A Trenton Thunder (4-2 win over Erie) 2B Gosuke Katoh: 1-4, 2 R, 1 2B, 1 BB, 1 K CF Rashad Crawford: 0-2, 1 R, 2 BB, 1 K RF Trey Amburgey: 2-3, 1 2B, 1 RBI, 1 BB — 6-for-16 (.375) in his last five games […] The post DotF: Sheffield and Nelson have strong starts appeared first on Ri […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Game 17: Sabathia’s Return April 19, 2018
    It’s no secret the Yankees have struggled to prevent runs so far this season. They’ve averaging 5.44 runs allowed per game, fifth most in baseball, and things have been especially bad lately. The Yankees have allowed at least six runs in six of their last seven games, and in seven of their last nine games. […] The post Game 17: Sabathia’s Return appeared fir […]
    Mike Axisa
  • 4/19 to 4/22 Series Preview: Toronto Blue Jays April 19, 2018
    Tonight’s game represents the first game in an eighteen games in eighteen days stretch, as the Yankees will not enjoy another day off until May 7. Will it allow the team to round into form, as players can finally (hopefully) get used to a consistent schedule? Or will it be as draining as most stretches […] The post 4/19 to 4/22 Series Preview: Toronto Blue J […]
    Domenic Lanza
  • Giancarlo Stanton’s trouble with the fastball April 19, 2018
    The first 16 games of the Giancarlo Stanton era have not gone according to plan. Well, 15 of the first 16 games have not gone according to plan. Opening Day was pretty rad. Overall though, Stanton is sitting on a .197/.293/.409 (96 wRC+) batting line with a 38.7% strikeout rate in the early going, and […] The post Giancarlo Stanton’s trouble with the fastbal […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Aaron Judge’s continually improving plate discipline April 19, 2018
    Sixteen games into the 2018 season, the Yankees have been mediocre and Aaron Judge has been awesome. Judge is hitting .339/.480/.593 (193 wRC+) in the early going, which is more or less in line with his numbers prior to the shoulder injury/second half slump last season. Aaron Judge, it appears, really is this damn good. […] The post Aaron Judge’s continually […]
    Mike Axisa
  • DotF: Thairo Estrada returns to action in Tampa’s win April 19, 2018
    Both RHP Anyelo Gomez and RHP Glenn Otto were placed on the 7-day DL today, it was announced. I have no idea what’s wrong with either guy. Gomez left last night’s start with an injury. Otto made his scheduled start last week and wasn’t put on the disabled list until today. Might be something minor, […] The post DotF: Thairo Estrada returns to action in Tampa […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Wednesday Night Open Thread April 18, 2018
    ?A Wednesday off-day? Weird. Can’t remember many of these over the years. The Yankees are off again today — between today’s off-day and the rainouts, they’ve played three games in the last six days — and tomorrow they’ll open an 18 games in 18 days stretch against contending teams. That’ll be fun. Anyway, check out […] The post Wednesday Night Open Thread ap […]
    Mike Axisa
  • Yankees reportedly re-sign Adam Lind to minor league deal April 18, 2018
    8:06pm ET: The Yankees have announced the signing. Lind is heading to Extended Spring Training on a minor league contract. 6:15pm ET: Welcome back, Adam Lind. The Yankees have re-signed the veteran first baseman to a new minor league contract, reports Chris Cotillo. Lind will head to Extended Spring Training to get up to speed. […] The post Yankees reportedl […]
    Mike Axisa

Blog Stats

  • 62,680 hits

%d bloggers like this: